Type of Credit: Partially Required
Credit(s)
Number of Students
本課程以介紹大學部學生史學研究的觀念、理論、方法和書寫策略上等相關課題為主,希望研習學生從歷史知識的「消費者」角色,逐漸成為「鑑賞者」和「生產者」的角色。課程的主軸是和學生一同探討思索,歷史知識的產生過程中,包含那些重要的方法、問題意識、主題、觀念架構、書寫技巧等因素的選擇組織和它們之間的配合及交互作用。
能力項目說明
通過本課程的訓練,有志於繼續深造的同學可以對正規學術研究的基本風貌有初步的了解,尤其是如何運用各種理論和方法於個人研究上;其他同學也可以從中反省檢討所學習的各類型歷史知識的特色和其可能的侷限性,進而對於史學知識的運用有更清楚的掌握。
1. What is History?: History as Memory, as Representation, as Invention, as Empirical Knowledge
2. History in Crisis: Peter Novick, In Defense of History, Telling the Truth about History, History on Trial: the Challenge of Multiculturalism
3. Nation and History: Anderson, Duara, History and Nation, 沈松僑, 梁啟超, 錢穆,
4. Marxism and History: Christopher Hill, Herman Ooms .
5. History from below: Labor History, Thompson
6. Women in History: Lydia Liu, Dorothy Ko, Female history review.
7. Emotion in History: Freud, Erikson, Loewenberg, Psychohistory, History of Mentality
8. Religion and Modernization: Max Weber, Rationalization
9. Image, (Sound) & Representation of the Past,
10. Representing the Other: Post-colonialism, Orientalism, , Edward Said/ Huntington
11. Knowledge, Power and Truth: Foucault, Bourdieu, Culture, Symbol, Dominance.
12. Discourse, History and Postmodernism: Language and History, Jenkins
*13. Science, Technology, and History: Social Darwinism, Kuhn( Paradigm)
主題單元的增減將視學生上課情況作彈性調整,各單元除講授基本概念外,相關講義和論文的研讀討論為上課的重點活動,同學必須預習指定讀物和參與課堂討論以及分組的口頭報告事宜;指定閱讀論文講義會在學期初全數上網,其他參考書籍同學可自行依課程進度閱讀。
平時成績(出席、上課發言討論/遠距討論、報告) 50%
期中考and/or 期末考 50%
*平時出席紀錄有3次以上(包含3次)缺席紀錄者,不得參與期中/期末考
*本課程有遠距數位學習網頁供同學進行課程討論,修課同學務必登錄以便上
網參與討論,並且留意網頁上的補充教材。
E. H. Carr, What is History? (江政寬譯,《何謂歷史》), Chapter 1.
John Tosh, “Historical Awareness,” The Pursuit of History, pp. 1-6.
Peter Burke, “History as Social Memory,” Varieties of Cultural History, pp.43-47; 56-59
Gary B. Nash, “In the Matter of History,” in History on Trial, pp.15-17.
Lynn Hunt, “Introduction,” Telling the Truth about History
理查.伊凡斯(Richard J. Evans)著; 潘振泰譯《為史學辯護》
Peter Novick, “There Was no King in Israel,” That Noble Dream pp. 612-621.
Craig Calhoun, “Nationalist Claims to History,” Nationalism pp.51-54
梁啟超, 〈中國之舊史學〉
沈松橋, 〈召喚沈默的亡者:我們需要怎樣的國族歷史?〉
Herman Ooms, “China in Nanga, Nanga in Tokugawa”
Christopher Hill, “Marxism and History”
劉禾, 〈女性身體與民族主義話語: 《生死場》〉;
* Lydia Liu, "The Female Body and Nationalist Discourse: Manchuria in Xiao Hong's Field of Life and Death" in Angela Zito and Tani Barlow, eds. Body, Subject, Power in China. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1994, pp.157- 177.
俞彥娟, 〈從婦女史和性別史的爭議談美國婦女史研究之發展〉, pp.207-225.
Paul A. Cohen, “Introduction,” Discovering History in China
徐復觀, 〈良知的迷惘----錢穆先生的史學〉
胡昌智, 〈 錢穆「國史大綱」的社會背景〉
王明珂, 〈民族史的邊緣研究: 一個史學與人類學的中介點〉
楊瑞松, 〈想像民族恥辱: 近代中國想思文化史上的「東亞病夫」〉
Peter Loewenberg, “On Psycohistory: A Statement on Method”, “Psyconanalysis and History: The Scope of the Problem” in Decoding the Past : the Psychohistorical Approach
周婉窈,〈面向過去而生〉,《面向過去而生》
周婉窈,〈高一生、家父和那被迫沈默的時代----在追思中思考我們的歷史命題〉,《面向過去而生》
Elias Norbert, “The Social Constraint towards Self-Constraint” in Power & Civility
Freud, Civilization and Its discontent
Lynn Hunt, “Preface”, The Family Romance of the French Revolution(中英對照)
Zeitlin, Irving M. “Max Weber” in Ideology and the Development of Sociological Theory
顧忠華,〈制慾與資本主義的精神〉,《韋伯的《基督新教倫理與資本主義精神》導讀》
顧忠華,〈基督心教倫理與儒家倫理──韋伯的文化比較研究〉,《韋伯的《基督新教倫理與資本主義精神導讀》
余英時的《中國近世宗教倫理與商人精神》, 序
Frank Dikötter, “Interoduction”, Narcotic Culture: A History of Drugs in China
黃宇和,〈讀史札記──論馮客的鴉片讚歌及其他〉,《中央研究院近代史研究所集刊》
石川禎浩,〈「華人與狗不得入內」告示牌問題考〉,《思想、政權與社會力量》
Herlihy David, “Am I a Camera? Other Reflections on Films and History”, The American Historical Review
張京媛,〈彼與此----愛德華‧薩伊德的《東方主義》〉
Said Edward, “Knowledge and Interpretation”, Covering Islam
Peter Burke, 〈第一章:路易十四進場〉,《製作路易十四》
顧忠華,〈台灣的現代性:誰的現代性?那種現代性〉,《當代》
Berkhofer Robert F., Historical Representations and Truthfulness in Beyond the Great Story: History as Text and Discourse.
凱斯‧詹京斯,〈歷史是什麼〉,《歷史的再思考》
Kertzer David I., “The Power of Rites”, in Ritual, Politics and Power.